Report: Strong Official Jobs Figures Way Off
MoneyNews
Wednesday, Aug. 3, 2005
(Headlines - scroll
down for full stories)
1. Report: Strong Official Jobs Figures
Way Off
2. Auto Sales Soar on GM Discount Initiative
3. Bonds Point to Sustained Global Growth
Story Continues Below
1. Report: Strong Official
Jobs Figures Way Off
A recent report from the Federal
Reserve Bank of Boston (FRBB) asserts that the U.S. government's claims of
strong employment figures and prosperity in America are simply inaccurate.
According to a new article from Adam
Porter of ResourceInvestor.com, a senior analyst at FRBB has "calculated the
effects of those who have left the American job market completely. In doing
so the FRBB estimate that 'an 8.7%
unemployment rate' could be nearer the truth that current government estimates.
Those sit at 5.1%."
If the FRBB's calculations are to be
believed, it would mean the United States is almost on a par with Europe in
terms of unemployment levels.
The article goes on to say that the
FRBB used the most recent figures available and found that "measured relative to
the business cycle peak in March 2001, labor force participation rates …have not
recovered as much as usual, and the discrepancies are large."
This implies that America's economic
recovery has not been as strong as was previously believed.
Katharine Bradbury, FRBB's senior
economist and policy adviser, authored the report and she points out that while
unemployment figures have fallen, "the percentage amount of the workforce
actually in work has remained relatively unchanged," the article states.
Bradbury says an unemployment figure
of 6.5% to 8.7% is probably more realistic than the government's 5.1% estimate.
Therefore, she says, "improvements
in total employment and the unemployment rate, as delayed and modest as they
have been, overstate the strength of the recovery, since the nation's labor
force participation rate has not rebounded to date."
And more disturbing: The
unemployment rate may have been understated going back as far as 2001.
Other experts agree that the
statistics contradict the government's employment numbers, as well as their
method of determining them.
A major indicator is the amount of
job advertisements in newspapers across the country.
According to the article, one
analysis of "help wanted" ads by the St. Louis Federal Reserve determined that
"from a starting point of 100 in 1987 the index had fallen in 2001 to 76 -- a
fall of 24% in fourteen years. Since 2001, however, this index has fallen to 38.
That is a further fall of 50% since 2001. This data also suggests a similar
firming up in 2005 to other employment calculations."
Of course there is an enormous
amount of information that must be compiled in order to assess employment levels
and determine levels of prosperity in America. Since data is gathered in many
different ways from so many different sources, there will most assuredly be
debate over the topic of employment for a long time to come.
2. Auto Sales Soar on GM Discount Initiative
There's nothing like a good
old-fashioned price cut to entice customers into the shop.
And auto industry results for July
proved that this approach still works, with Ford and Chrysler announcing a
25%-plus sales boost as a result of the industry-wide employee initiative
introduced by GM.
General Motors saw car sales rise
20% and truck sales spike 35% as it announced that employee discount pricing
will remain available to customers through September 6. Ford later matched the
move.
Sales of cars and light trucks
soared to 18.8 million from 17.2 million a year ago.
Both Ford and GM are fighting
against continued marketshare declines in the face of import penetration from
overseas. Some twenty years ago, GM's North American marketshare was at 43.3%.
That now matches what both it and Ford control today.
The longer these discounts remain in
place, the more damage Ford and GM will inflict on the Asian competitors.
However, does a permanent price reduction make sense when the victory would be
merely a battle won in the much larger war against the competition?
Asian branding has become firmly
entrenched, built upon reliability combined with value. So it might take more
than a summer-long price cut to win this war.
However, there's no doubting the
success of the employee-discounting campaigns.
Although dealers complained about
running dry of inventory, the end result must have brought smiles back to their
faces.
But the real winner will be the
economy -- as the incentive will provide a jumpstart to manufacturing.
3. Bonds Point to Sustained Global Growth
Take a quick look at the world's equity markets and you'll see
that investors are more optimistic than at any time since 2001 -- when the slump
in growth and equities began.
Behind the move is growing confidence in corporate earnings,
thanks to strengthening global demand.
The fact that the U.S. consumer has continually picked up the
slack plays no small part, but the emergence of Brazil, China and India as
viable economic forces is equally important.
Another way of checking the global pulse is through bond prices.
Interest rates or yields on government bonds (debt) are a key
way to tell just how much conviction investors have in economic activity.
Bonds are driven by the prospects for inflation, growth and the
mood of each central bank, which sets official monetary policy.
Despite relatively robust growth accompanied by a lack of
inflationary pressures, bonds have come off the boil in the recent month.
The reason is simple.
Dealers have been wrong in their collective pessimism that
global growth is stalling. Add to that the fact that the Federal Reserve
continues to talk tough about the need for future rate increases.
Suddenly, the fall in bond prices throughout July makes sense.
In America, the benchmark 10-year yield has risen 43 basis
points from 3.92 to 4.35% since late June.
A firm housing market and forward-looking survey evidence that
manufacturers are set to ramp up production have caused bond traders to question
the current low-yield environment.
In Europe, the central bank has been vindicated in its mantra
that there was no need to reduce rock-bottom interest rates. Recent Purchasing
Managers data show that the economy was merely in a transition and that growth
will resume (as they predicted) in the second half.
Factor in an apparent end to the decline of the euro and the ECB
has things under control.
Still, yields on the benchmark 10-year German government bond
have surged from 3.09% in July -- when dealers screamed for interest rates to be
cut -- to 3.36%.
Even in the UK, where the Bank of England may cut official
interest rates as early as this week, 10-year bond yields have risen from 4.12
to 4.40%. And economists have pared back their views on just how weak domestic
growth really is.
The international background has improved and demand has
returned -- taking most economists by surprise.
The yield funk may continue for some time.
Bond markets have a strange tendency to head for round numbers
before taking change to heart. It wouldn't surprise us to see yields head into
the 4.50-4.75% window for the U.S. 10-year note.
The recent announcement by the U.S. Treasury Department that it
will relaunch the 30-year bond is testimony to the fact that rates should
continue to rise. The huge budget deficit needs to be financed, and by locking
into low long-dated maturities, the Treasury is ensuring that it keeps
taxpayers' costs to a minimum.