Bush and Annan Spar Over War in Iraq
NewsMax.com Wires
Wednesday, Sept. 22, 2004
UNITED NATIONS After two years, the United States and the
United Nations had hoped to take the spotlight off the bitterly
divisive war in Iraq. It didn't happen. At the opening of the U.N.
General Assembly, President Bush and U.N. Secretary-General Kofi
Annan sparred over the war that can't escape the headlines.
Annan made news last week when, for the first time, he said the
U.S.-led war that toppled Saddam Hussein was "illegal." Bush, defending his Iraq policy Tuesday before world leaders and ministers
from 191 countries, said that a ruthless dictator had been toppled and that Iraq was now "on the path to democracy and freedom."
Story Continues Below
The secretary-general also took aim at the United States in his
General Assembly speech, warning world leaders that basic laws to
protect civilians are being "shamelessly disregarded" around the
world from Iraq and Sudan to Russia and Uganda.
In his list of violations of the rule of law, he cited "Iraqi
prisoners flagrantly abused," clearly a criticism of the U.S.
treatment of detainees at Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad. He also
noted, without naming names, that at times "the necessary fight
against terrorism is allowed to encroach unnecessarily on civil
liberties."
Iraq has been a dominant theme for Bush at the United Nations
since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. At the General Assembly
ministerial meeting in 2002, he laid out the U.S. case against
Saddam. The U.N. Security Council rejected it, refusing to
authorize the U.S.-led war and creating one of the most serious
divisions in the United Nations since its founding in 1945.
Bush warned that the United Nations risked becoming irrelevant.
But at last fall's General Assembly, six months after the war, he
appealed for international support to rebuild Iraq, and he repeated
that appeal on Tuesday.
This year, with just six weeks before the U.S. presidential
election, Bush softened his speech to discuss the "great issues of
our time," such as fighting AIDS, human slavery, poverty, the
violence in Sudan, corruption and human cloning. He also
appealed for greater efforts to fight terrorism and "to promote hope
and progress as the alternatives to hatred and violence."
"Our great purpose is to build a better world beyond the war on
terror," Bush said.
He proposed establishing a Democracy Fund in the United Nations,
pledging an initial unspecified contribution and urging other
nations to donate to the fund, which would help countries lay the
foundations of democracy by instituting the rule of law,
independent courts, a free press, political parties and trade
unions.
Despite the past differences with the United Nations, not just
on Iraq but over the perception of U.S. unilateralism, the
president paid tribute to the world body and its chief in a toast
at a luncheon Tuesday hosted by Annan for world leaders.
Bush's 'Admiration' for Annan
"Mr. Secretary-General," Bush said, raising his glass, "with
admiration for your leadership, and with confidence in this
organization, I offer a toast to you and your service, and to the
United Nations."
The tribute pleased several diplomats, who saw it as a
recognition that the Bush administration has recognized that it
needs the United Nations, and can't operate as a lone superpower.
"When all is said and done," said Swiss President Joseph
Deiss, "the Iraq crisis has shown us that the international
community remains attached to a multilateral system for maintaining
international peace and security, but that the structures currently
in place are no longer appropriate."
"There is now a clear need for reform and for strengthening the
means of joint action," he said.
U.N. reform, which is expected to be tackled at next year's
General Assembly session, was a topic in many speeches on
Tuesday's opening of the two-week ministerial debate. So was the
need to close the widening gap between rich and poor.
President Abel Pacheco de la Espriella of Costa Rica called for
a fairer world economic system, noting that in 2003, the world
reached a new record by devoting $956 billion to military
expenditure. That is 17 times the amount of resources devoted to
development assistance and more than the sum of the foreign debt of
the 64 countries with the lowest GDP, he said.
"These numbers show that mankind has not understood yet that
security does not result from a multiplication of the weapons but
from a multiplication of the loaves of bread," Pacheco said.
Lula's Agenda
Brazilian President Luis Inacio Lula da Silva appealed for
economic and social justice in a world where the disparity in per-capita income between the richest and poorest nations is now 16
times greater than it was nearly two decades ago.
As one example of the human cost, he said, a lack of basic
sanitation has killed more children in the past decade than all
military conflicts since the end of World War II.
© 2004 Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Editor's note:
The U.N.’s Dangerous Agenda – read NewsMax’s special report – Click Here
Read more on this subject in related Hot Topics:
Bush Administration
George W. Bush
Latin America
Middle East
Saddam Hussein/Iraq
United Nations
War on Terrorism