U.S. Voters in Foreign Nations Could Decide the Election
NewsMax.com Wires
Monday, Aug. 16, 2004
NEW YORK – When decision time comes this fall, the real
swing votes in the 2004 presidential election might not come from
Pennsylvania, Ohio or even the notorious Florida. The ultimate
Bush-Kerry battleground could turn out to be somewhere more far-flung
and unexpected: Israel, Britain, even Indonesia.
Both political camps say they are getting ready for the
fight, courting American voters who are living overseas and taking
no chances that the expatriate vote will undermine them at the
finish line.
Story Continues Below
Although an official census has never been taken, between 4
million and 10 million American citizens are believed to be living
abroad. Those over 18 are entitled to have their absentee votes
counted in the state where they last lived, no matter how long ago
that was. And many are planning to do just that.
"There's enormous interest abroad, because the whole of the
world depends on the result," said Phyllis Earl, 72, who lives in
Britain and has not voted in a U.S. election since 1956, two years
after she moved overseas.
Overseas voters are considered particularly important this year.
Polls suggest razor-thin margins in several battleground states,
and votes coming in from abroad - a score here, a dozen there -
could well tip the balance.
Contrary to widespread belief, it was more likely American
voters in Israel, not Florida, who put George W. Bush in the White
House four years ago, a phenomenon that has Kerry's supporters in
Israel vowing to do whatever it takes to make certain that doesn't
happen again in November.
Kerry's sister Diana speaks several languages and has been using
them all in campaign swings throughout Europe. Sharon Manitta,
spokeswoman for the group Democrats Abroad, said Kerry's supporters
had been active in "overseas outreach efforts" in Europe,
Indonesia, Mexico and even Iran. In 2000, the organization had 30
overseas chapters; now it has a presence in 73 countries,
including an Iraq chapter called "Donkeys in the Desert."
Bush, too, has advocates chasing the overseas vote on his
behalf, according to Ryan King, deputy director of Republicans
Abroad, which has chapters in 50 countries. Among those crossing
the oceans for Bush this fall are former Vice President Dan Quayle
and George P. Bush, son of the president's brother, Florida Gov.
Jeb Bush.
"Be an expatriate patriot," says an ad planned by Republicans
Abroad that also quotes former President Ronald Reagan: "We cannot
play innocents abroad in a world that is not innocent."
After Labor Day, Republicans Abroad also plans campaign ads on
the president's behalf in the International Herald Tribune and in
Stars and Stripes, a newspaper with wide distribution among the
estimated 300,000 to 400,000 U.S. military personnel serving
abroad.
Voters in Israel Decided the 2000 Election
Those who doubt that Americans living abroad could tip the
balance in 2004 might consider this: Chads aside, Al Gore
received 202 more votes than George W. Bush on Election Day 2000 in
Florida. Only after all the overseas votes were counted, including
more than 12,000 from Israel alone, was Bush's election victory
certified. The margin was 537 votes.
In 2000, according to King, Israel was one of the keys to Bush's
success. No other foreign country's U.S. citizens contributed more
to Bush's narrow Florida victory, he said.
Harvard Professor Gary King, co-compiler of a survey analyzing
Florida's overseas vote in 2000, has no doubt that expatriate
Americans gave Bush his victory four years ago. And while it's
unclear whether the vote from Israel alone was enough to put Bush
over the top, 185,000 U.S. citizens live there, an undetermined
number from Florida.
Mark Zober, chairman of Democrats Abroad in Israel, said he had
no firm figures but estimated that roughly 100,000 Americans in
Israel were eligible to vote in the U.S. election in November, and that
roughly 14,000 were registered in 2000.
But how could Israeli Jews give Bush his margin of victory when
Jewish Democrats outnumber Jewish Republicans by a wide margin in
the United States? Both Zober and Ryan King think they know the
answer.
Zober sees little doubt that the Jewish vote in New York
heavily favored Gore. But in the 2000 presidential election, Zober
points out, it made no difference how Israeli immigrants from New
York voted. All that mattered was how expatriates from Florida cast
their ballots.
Israel is home to roughly 6,000 former Floridians, expatriates
who tend to be more conservative than Jewish voters in New York and
many of whom voted for Bush in the last election, Zober said.
Additionally, he said in a telephone interview from his office
in Tel Aviv, many Israeli-Americans who might have voted for Gore
if they were living in the United States voted for Bush because
they considered him an unflinching supporter of Israel.
Once in Israel, Zober said, Jewish voters are no longer guided
by a presidential candidate's position on domestic issues. Instead,
he said, they vote for whoever they think will serve Israel's
interests. Even this year, Zober acknowledged, many
American-Israelis are still inclined "to vote for the devil they
know instead of the one they don't."
No statistics exist to predict definitively whether Americans in
Israel will play such an important role this November. But Marc
Zell, chairman of Republicans Abroad's Israel chapter, is taking no
chances.
Zell said his group had about 150 volunteers who aggressively
started registering potential Bush voters a few months ago. As the
election nears, he said, they will be holding "parlor sessions"
at their homes to discuss Bush's support for Israel and will
probably take out pro-Bush ads in Israel's English-language
newspapers.
The Democrat group, meanwhile, is hoping to show
American-Israelis that their adopted home is no safer today than
before the war in Iraq and that Kerry is no less a friend to Israel
than Bush.
Israel is hardly the only country Bush and Kerry supporters are
turning to for votes. Registration drives are under way in
countries across Europe, Asia and Latin America. And in Britain,
home to an estimated 224,000 American expatriates, voter interest
is greater than ever, according to Democrats and Republicans alike.
Timothy Spangler, who heads Britain's branch of Republicans
Abroad, said Bush's chief political adviser, Karl Rove, had come to
London on the president's behalf, as had Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and
Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham. This fall, Republicans Abroad
plans to take advantage of voter interest by sending
representatives to register voters at businesses that employ many
Americans.
Democrats in Britain are doing much the same thing, registering
expatriates who have been living there for decades as nonvoters.
Manitta said her group had set up a booth outside her movie
house in Salisbury, about 85 miles southwest of London, to register
potential Kerry voters leaving Michael Moore's "Fahrenheit 9/11."
Earl, who moved to London in 1954, will vote this year for only
the second time in her life, not because she wants to, she says,
but because she's afraid of what might happen if she doesn't cast
her ballot against incumbents who she feels "don't have the
interest of the country at heart."
"The situation is desperate," Earl said. "For me, it reached
a critical point. I just felt I had to vote."
Editor's note:
Urgent: President Bush needs your support – Click Here Now and show your support to your friends and family
Read more on this subject in related Hot Topics:
Al Gore
Presidential Race 2000
2004 Elections
Bush Administration
DNC
George W. Bush
Israel
Middle East
RNC
Sen John Kerry
War on Terrorism