Rumsfeld Makes Surprise Visit to Iraq, Denounces Media's 'Garbage'
NewsMax.com Wires
Thursday, May 13, 2004
BAGHDAD, Iraq – Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld,
making a surprise visit to Iraq aimed at containing the prisoner
abuse scandal, said Thursday that administration lawyers were advising
the Pentagon not to publicly release any more photographs of Iraqi
prisoners being abused by U.S. soldiers.
"As far as I'm concerned, I'd be happy to release them all to
the public and to get it behind us," Rumsfeld told reporters
traveling with him from Washington. "But at the present time I
don't know anyone in the legal shop in any element of the
government that is recommending that."
The government lawyers argue that releasing such materials would
violate a Geneva Convention stricture against presenting images of
prisoners that could be construed as degrading, Rumsfeld said en
route to the Iraqi capital on a trip that was not announced in
advance due to security concerns.
Rumsfeld was accompanied by Gen. Richard Myers, chairman of the
Joint Chiefs of Staff, and several lawyers on a trip designed to
reassure U.S. troops that the prisoner abuse scandal has not
weakened public support for their mission and to get firsthand
reports from the most senior commanders.
The Pentagon officials arranged meetings with the top U.S.
commander in Iraq, Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, and other senior
commanders.
Sanchez told reporters accompanying Rumsfeld that it appeared Abu
Musab al-Zarqawi, an associate of Osama bin Laden believed to be
behind a wave of suicide bombings in Iraq, was responsible for
killing Nicholas Berg, a young American beheaded by hooded men in
an execution shown in a video posted on the Internet.
"All indications are that is the case," said Sanchez. Asked
whether he meant Zarqawi personally carried out the execution,
Sanchez said, "All indications are he did it."
Later, however, Sanchez said it wasn't clear that Zarqawi was
present at the killing. "I don't know whether he was personally
holding the knife or in the room," Sanchez said. "I do not know
that."
Asked about Zarqawi's whereabouts, the general said, "We
believe he's movng around the country."
Rumsfeld's trip followed President Bush's visit Monday to the
Pentagon, where he got an update from commanders in Iraq and
declared his unwavering support for Rumsfeld, who has taken a lot
of criticism from members of Congress for his handling of the
scandal. Some Democrats have called for his resignation, but
Rumsfeld gave no indication Wednesday that he was considering
quitting.
The 71-year-old defense chief did appear weary, however. He has
weathered three lengthy rounds of questioning from congressional
committees over the past several days. After taking questions
aboard his plane for nearly an hour he called a sudden halt, saying
his voice was giving out.
'The Garbage You Keep Reading'
He fiercely defended the Pentagon's response to the revelations
of U.S. guards at the Abu Ghraib prison having subjected Iraqi
prisoners to sexually humiliating treatment and photographing it.
"The garbage that you keep reading, about cover-up and the
Pentagon doing something to keep some information from people, is
unfair, inaccurate and wrong," he said. "And if I find any
evidence that it's true, I'll stop it."
Rumsfeld predicted that the abuse scandal would get worse
in the days ahead.
"More bad things will come out, unquestionably," he said
without being specific. "And time will settle over this, and we'll
be able to make an assessment of what the effect has been" on the
effort to stabilize Iraq. "It clearly has not been helpful. It has
been unhelpful."
Arab Media Even Worse Than U.S. Media
He went on to complain bitterly about the Arab media's coverage
of U.S. operations in Iraq.
"We have been lied about, day after day, week after week, month
after month for the last 12 months in the Arab press." He
specifically mentioned the al-Jazeera and al-Arabiya satellite TV
networks.
In a separate interview, Maj. Gen. Geoffrey Miller, who runs the
prison system in Iraq, defended his role in advising U.S.
authorities last fall on how to set up a detention and
interrogation system that would produce useful intelligence on
people involved in the insurgency.
"I'm absolutely convinced we laid down the fo undations for how
you detain people humanely ," he said. Miller said he plans to
reduce the prisoner population at Abu Ghraid from the 3,800 who are
there now to as few as 1,500 by June 15. In January, there were
about 7,000 prisoners there, he said.
Among his first responses to the international outcry over the
abuse photos, Rumsfeld sent Vice Adm. Albert T. Church, the Navy's
top investigative officer, to the U.S.-run prison camp for
terrorist suspects at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, last week. Church, who
accompanied Rumsfeld on his trip to Iraq, told reporters en route
from Washington that he found no major problems at that prison in
Cuba.
"The directions of the secretary of defense with respect to the
humane treatment of detainees and the interrogation techniques were
being carried out, as best we could determine," Church said. "We
found minor infractions involving contact with detainees, and we
documented eight of those."
Bad Haircut vs. Beheading
Of the eight, four were violations by military police soldiers
who guard the detainees at Guantanamo Bay, three were violations by
interrogators, and one was a barber who gave a detainee an
"unauthorized haircut," a Mohawk-style cut that Church said
amounted to humiliating the prisoner.
One of the violators, who punched a detainee in handcuffs, was
punished by having his rank reduced, Church said.
Church said he felt confident in saying there currently were no
major lapses in the humane treatment of Guantanamo prisoners, but
he added that he could not be 100 percent sure because he took
sworn testimony from only 43 people there, in addition to reviewing
medical records of 100 detainees.
"We found no evidence of current abuse. Again I underline
`current,'" he said.
Church was at Guantanamo Bay for two days last week. An
assistant took a one-day look at the situation at the brig at
Charleston Naval Station, S.C. Church did not mention what was
found there.
© 2004 Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Editor's note:
Free Offer – get up to $60 in books FREE with NewsMax Magazine – Click Here Now
Read more on this subject in related Hot Topics:
Bush Administration
Media Bias
Middle East
Saddam Hussein/Iraq
War on Terrorism