Defeat Expected in Fla. Brain-Damage Case
NewsMax.com Wires
Wednesday, Dec. 24, 2003
CLEARWATER, Fla. A judge said Tuesday he was ready to rule
on the constitutionality of a state law that has been keeping a
severely brain-damaged woman alive, and a lawyer for Gov. Jeb Bush
predicted the law would be overturned.
Circuit Court Judge W. Douglas Baird, at a routine hearing in
the case of Terri Schiavo, said he had heard everything he needed and would rule once a court settles appeals filed by the governor's
office.
Even though Baird did not indicate which way he would rule, Bush
attorney Ken Connor said he believed Baird intended to rule that the
law, hastily passed in October to keep Mrs. Schiavo alive,
is unconstitutional because it violates her right to privacy.
Her husband, Michael Schiavo, says she would not want to be kept
alive artificially. Her parents want to keep her alive and see if
she will respond to therapy.
Florida courts repeatedly have said Schiavo has the
right to remove the feeding tube that has kept her alive. The tube
was removed in October, and she went without water and nutrition for
six days until the Legislature and the governor stepped in to have
the tube reinserted.
Appeals pending in the 2nd District Court in Lakeland center on
whether a suit Schiavo filed challenging the governor's
intervention was filed in the right venue and whether the
governor's attorneys should be allowed to question certain
witnesses in the case.
No timetable has been set for a decision by the appellate court.
During the hearing Tuesday, Schiavo's attorney argued
that the governor gave himself unchecked powers to override Mrs. Schiavo's personal medical decision, as conveyed by her husband,
and urged the court not to allow it.
But Connor argued that the governor was acting to protect a
disabled woman who is part of a population of Floridians who are
"particularly vulnerable."
The new law provides an extra layer of protection in cases where
there are no written directives by requiring an independent
advocate be appointed to represent a patient's interests.
© 2003 Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Editor's note:
Find the secrets to long life from the Mayo Clinic – Click here now
Read more on this subject in related Hot Topics:
Health Issues